Y’all know I love musical lists. So when Rolling Stone made a list of the “The 100 Greatest Singers of All Time” I was all giddy with excitement.
But, I gotta say, the list puzzles me. I know all lists are subjective and subject to argument. But some things about this one just makes me wonder. What criteria were used?
I mean, is Bob Dylan one of the greatest musical geniuses this world has ever seen? Sure. Is he a great singer. Um, no. But there he is in the #7 spot. Is the list of most influential singers? Then I’d agree. But RS said “best.” I’m perplexed.
Anywho, here are my initial thoughts about the list, good and bad.
The really good stuff about the list:
-Aretha Franklin tops it.
-The essay about Aretha Franklin’s awesomeness was written by Mary J. Blige. I have always said that Mary J. is the Gen X version of Aretha. (The fact that she is #100 on the list is bulls***, but I degress…)
-It includes oft-forgotten artists like Curtis Mayfield, Dusty Springfield, Bobby “Blue” Bland, and Donny Hathaway. Nice!
-It crosses genres. Buddy Holly is on the same list as Björk. Good stuff.
The really bad stuff about the list:
-Only 24 of the 100 are women. I agree with Jezebel that that is total bulls***.
-Some of the omissions are shocking. More on that below.
-Hey RS: Look at the bottom ten on your list. Now grab Annie Lennox, Karen Carpenter, Patti LaBelle, B.B. King, Joe Cocker, Stevie Nicks, Mary J. Blige, and yes, even Steven Tyler (listen to Dream On, people!!), and pull them all the @#%& out of the bottom and put them in the top half, at least!! I mean really!! They’re below Morrissey?! What the hell?!
Here are, in my opinion, but a few singers who shoulda been on this list, no matter what criteria were used:
Ella Fitzgerald. Ok, I’ll give RS Aretha for the #1 spot. But in what universe is Ella not number two? (Props to RS that the other four women on my Vocal Wish List are on their list too. But Ella is still a glaring omission.)
UPDATE: I woke up and realized a HUGE omission, almost as big as Ella’s:
Barbra Streisand. That’s right, no BARBRA! I don’t even know what to say. This omission makes me think that the list is such bulls*** that’s it’s not even worth commenting on anymore. I’m sad that it’s going to be cited by people as authority for the next 50 years.
Bon Scott and/or Brian Johnson. These were actually suggested by my boyfriend, and may have something to do with the fact that we’re seeing AC/DC this weekend. But it raises a good point – yesterday I thought – because it’s Rolling Stone – maybe the list is slanted towards rock artists at the expense of other genres. But that can’t be true – no rock list would omit Bon. Brian’s nothing to sneeze at either. Plus the list includes blues, jazz, r&b, folk singers. Steve Perry’s on it, for Pete’s sake! (I agree with that choice completely, but it shows that even easy listening is included!)
Levi Stubbs. They included David Ruffin, and good for them! Levi’s absence is still noticed. Listen to Baby I Need Your Lovin’ or Bernadette and then tell me what’s what. (The man voiced Audrey II the plant in Little Shop of Horrors! Come on!)
Chaka Khan. Her voice is a wonder of the world.
Mahalia Jackson. I defy you to watch Imitation of Life and not cry when Mahalia sings in this scene. I defy you not to cry whenever Mahalia sings.
Eddie Vedder. I mean, if you’re gonna have Bono and Kurt Cobain, how can you forget Eddie? I mean damn!
Sarah Vaughan. She could sing half of the people on this list under a table.
Diana Ross. Ok, she isn’t the strongest singer on the planet – but I sense that this list is more about the biggest hit makers, or most iconic singers, or most notable singers, or most prolific singers (because really, can Bono really belt it?). In any of those cases, Diana qualifies. She ruled 60s, 70s, and a good chunk of the 80s charts.
UPDATE: On the subway ride home I thought of more: Roberta Flack; Neil Diamond; Ann Wilson of Heart; Billie Holiday; Billy Joel.
What do you think? Comment away!